Article illustration 1

For decades, personal aviation has been trapped in a cycle of stagnation. While commercial air travel advanced in safety and cost-efficiency, general aviation—particularly small, owner-flown aircraft—languished under restrictive regulations. The dream of practical "flying cars" remained elusive, with innovation stifled by cumbersome certification processes and arbitrary limits. Now, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is challenging this status quo with its MOSAIC (Modernization of Special Airworthiness Certification) rulemaking, a bold proposal that could redefine the future of personal flight by leveraging a nuanced safety continuum to spur technological breakthroughs.

The Safety Continuum: FAA's Framework for Balanced Regulation

At its core, the FAA operates on a "safety continuum" that tailors regulatory rigor to risk. As detailed in the source material, this spectrum ranges from heavily regulated Part 25 airliners (targeting one catastrophic event per billion flight-hours) to minimally controlled ultralights. Light-sport aircraft (LSAs), introduced in 2004, occupy a middle ground—requiring consensus standards like ASTM but avoiding full type certification. This approach fosters innovation while managing hazards: experimental aircraft allow rapid iteration, while certified models ensure passenger safety. As Eli Dourado notes in the source article, this continuum is crucial for engineering progress, providing an on-ramp for technologies like composite materials that eventually migrated to airliners.

"If certification requirements and oversight are overly stringent, safety can be jeopardized because the burden of certification will prevent the adoption of safety-enhancing technologies." — FAA, as cited in the source.

MOSAIC builds on this philosophy by expanding the LSA category to entice pilots away from riskier experimental aircraft. Data shows LSAs have roughly half the fatal accident rate of experimental amateur-built (EAB) planes. By making LSAs more attractive, the FAA aims to shift flight-hours to safer operations—a counterintuitive strategy where deregulation enhances overall safety.

MOSAIC's Transformative Technical Changes

Under the proposed rule, key limitations on LSAs are lifted, opening doors for cutting-edge designs:

  • Weight and Speed Unleashed: The current 1,320-pound weight cap and 120-knot speed limit are eliminated. LSAs could now weigh up to ~3,000 pounds and cruise at 250 knots—more than doubling speed potential. Retractable landing gear will be permitted to reduce drag, enabling efficient high-speed travel.
  • Expanded Propulsion and Seating: The single reciprocating engine requirement is scrapped, allowing turboprops, electric motors, or hybrid systems like turbogenerators powering distributed electric propulsion (DEP). This supports eVTOL development. Airplanes can also have up to four seats (though sport pilots remain limited to one passenger), targeting private pilots who currently use experimental four-seaters.
  • Simplified Flight Controls: A game-changer for accessibility, MOSAIC allows "simplified flight controls" where pilots use arcade-style inputs (e.g., "turn left" commands) while the aircraft handles envelope protection. This could democratize flying by reducing skill barriers, with model-specific endorsements ensuring safety.
Article illustration 4

Fatal accident rates per 100,000 flight-hours highlight LSAs' safety edge over experimental aircraft—a gap MOSAIC aims to widen. (Source: FAA data via Eli Dourado)

Implications for Developers and the Aviation Ecosystem

This deregulation could ignite a flywheel of innovation. Without type certification, manufacturers can iterate rapidly on designs, incorporate uncertified avionics, and deploy over-the-air software updates. Technologies like DEP, STOL (short takeoff and landing) capabilities, and active turbulence reduction become feasible in affordable platforms. For instance, a MOSAIC-compliant aircraft with 200-knot speeds, 1,000-nautical-mile range, and Starlink connectivity could emerge—blurring lines between personal and commercial aviation.

The eVTOL sector stands to gain immensely, as MOSAIC explicitly includes powered-lift aircraft under LSA rules. While initial pilot requirements may limit operations, it lowers barriers for startups to prototype and test without billion-dollar certifications. As Dourado argues, mass manufacturing could eventually reduce costs, though supply-chain rigor will keep prices above consumer cars.

A Catalyst for Broader Change

MOSAIC is a rare example of regulatory wisdom: it acknowledges that past over-regulation contributed to aviation's stagnation and corrects it by aligning rules with real-world safety data. By embracing the safety continuum, the FAA not only promises fewer accidents but also accelerates advancements in aerospace tech—from electric propulsion to autonomous systems. For engineers and tech leaders, this signals fertile ground for R&D in adaptive control algorithms, energy-efficient powertrains, and lightweight materials.

Yet, as the source notes, this rule also underscores decades of missed opportunities. If adopted earlier, such flexible frameworks might have prevented the decline of personal aviation. As MOSAIC moves toward finalization (comments close January 2024), its success could inspire similar deregulatory approaches in other high-stakes fields like advanced nuclear reactors, proving that safety and innovation thrive when regulations evolve with technology.

Source: Eli Dourado via elidourado.com