The Faintest Whispers vs. the Loudest Neighbor

Deep in the radio-quiet expanse of Western Australia, astronomers are building humanity's most sensitive ear to the cosmos: the Square Kilometre Array Low-frequency telescope (SKA-Low). Designed to detect signals stretched and faded over 13 billion years—emanating from the era when the first stars ignited—its mission hinges on extreme sensitivity in the 50-350 MHz band. But a new report from the International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR) reveals a terrestrial threat drowning out these cosmic murmurs: Elon Musk's Starlink megaconstellation.

Article illustration 1

The SKA-Low prototype telescope in Western Australia faces a growing threat from unintended satellite emissions. (Credit: Supplied/SKAO)

78 Million Images, 112,000 Unwanted Guests

Testing with the EDA2 prototype telescope delivered alarming results. Over 29 days, analyzing 78 million full-sky images, researchers detected over 112,000 signals originating from 1,506 different Starlink satellites. Crucially, these weren't just the satellites' intended communications transmissions, which operate in licensed bands. These were unintended electromagnetic emissions (EMI) – electromagnetic 'noise' leaking from the satellites' internal electronics, akin to the static heard when holding an AM radio near a computer.

The problem lies in scale and sensitivity. While individual satellite EMI might be within regulatory limits, the sheer number of Starlink craft – now numbering in the thousands and growing rapidly – creates a cacophony. For SKA-Low, designed to detect signals quintillions of times fainter than a mobile phone, this EMI can be up to 100,000 times (5 orders of magnitude) stronger than their celestial targets. "Starlink is that tinted-windowed, over-specced car, blowing out windows with its bass," the source aptly notes.

Direct-to-Cell: Amplifying the Problem

The planned Starlink direct-to-cell service exacerbates the issue significantly. Unlike standard user terminals with high-gain, tracking antennas, cellphones have tiny antennas and low-power transmitters designed for nearby towers. To bridge the 500+ km gap to a Starlink satellite, the spacecraft must transmit with massively amplified power – adhering to the brutal inverse square law (signal strength diminishes with the square of distance).

"A signal 500 km away isn't 500 times weaker than one at one kilometer, it's 250,000 times weaker. The satellite's transmitter has to compensate by upping its power accordingly."

This concentrated, high-power downlink beam acts like a celestial searchlight, potentially overwhelming telescope sensors even when operating in different frequency bands. Traditional filtering occurs after the initial signal detection, offering limited protection against such intense, nearby sources.

A Glimmer of Hope: SpaceX, SETI, and the RF Priesthood

Amidst the interference static, a potential solution is tuning in. SpaceX has demonstrated notable responsiveness to astronomical concerns, driven partly by the shared expertise of RF engineers (the "RF Priesthood") and its rapid iteration capabilities. More concretely, SpaceX has partnered with the SETI Institute to form a dedicated industry group focused on mitigating satellite interference with astronomy.

This collaboration aims to transform ad-hoc fixes into a formalized engineering discipline. The involvement of SETI – long at the forefront of searching for faint cosmic signals, albeit for intelligence – lends significant scientific credibility. The challenge now is ensuring broad industry participation and establishing robust, enforceable standards before proliferating satellite swarms render unique radio-quiet zones obsolete.

Listening to the Dawn, or Drowning it Out?

The standoff isn't merely technical; it's philosophical. SKA-Low represents a multi-billion dollar, decades-long investment in understanding our universe's origins. Starlink promises global connectivity. Balancing these goals demands more than technical patches; it requires acknowledging that the pristine electromagnetic spectrum is a finite resource for discovery. If unmitigated, the unintended radio roar from thousands of satellites won't just photobomb our images of the stars – it could permanently deafen us to the birth of the cosmos itself. The success of the SpaceX-SETI alliance will determine whether we prioritize fleeting connectivity over understanding eternity.