Article illustration 1

The Surveillance Infrastructure Already in Place

France's renewed push to legalize real-time facial recognition isn't just political theater—it's built on a pre-existing technical foundation. As detailed by researcher Félix Tréguer in an op-ed for La Quadrature du Net, three critical components already exist:

  1. Sensor Network: Over 90,000 public video surveillance cameras blanket French streets, acting as continuous facial image collection points.
  2. Biometric Databases: Systems like the TAJ (Criminal Record Processing) database store nearly 10 million facial photos, while the TES (Secure Electronic Documents) file contains facial prints from all ID/passport holders.
  3. AI Backbone: Algorithms from companies like Idemia and Thales—refined through taxpayer-funded R&D—can now rapidly match live feeds against these databases with improved accuracy.

"Going out in public with your face uncovered would be like harboring a forgery-proof ID card readable by the government at any time," warns Tréguer. "Anonymity becomes virtually impossible."

Regulatory Chess: How the AI Act Enables Surveillance Creep

The EU's landmark AI Act, marketed as banning real-time biometric surveillance, contains critical exemptions France aggressively championed:

  • Terrorism Prevention: Permits facial scanning for "genuine and foreseeable" terrorist threats
  • Broad Criminal Investigations: Authorizes use for crimes punishable by 4+ years—including environmental activism
  • Sensitive Inference: Allows algorithms to deduce race, political views, or sexual orientation from morphology

This creates a concerning precedent: algorithmic systems could resurrect pseudoscientific racial profiling under state sanction.

The Developer's Dilemma: Ethics vs. Innovation

France's facial recognition market is projected to reach $12 billion by 2028, fueled by:
- Public R&D subsidies via Research Tax Credits
- Bpifrance investments
- Olympic Games "testbeds" (despite inconclusive 2023 results)

Engineers building these systems face ethical trade-offs: optimizing identification algorithms inevitably aids mass surveillance. As Tréguer notes, these technologies reduce human faces to "mere anatomical features"—raw data for state control.

Why This Threatens Digital Democracy

Real-time facial recognition enables what a French gendarmerie colonel candidly termed "invisible, permanent, and universal identity checks." Technical implementation would:

  • Eliminate Public Anonymity: Faces become mandatory digital IDs
  • Chill Dissent: Activists could be automatically tracked via political insignia detection
  • Enable Historical Abuses: As Tréguer starkly observes, such systems would have doomed WWII resistance networks

With infrastructure already operational in airports and train stations, the battle shifts from technical feasibility to political will—making developer awareness and ethical scrutiny critical.

Source: Félix Tréguer, researcher at La Quadrature du Net, via original op-ed