Inbox Surveillance: 80% of Retailers Embed Tracking Pixels in Holiday Emails

A comprehensive report from Proton Mail reveals that 80% of major US retailers are using hidden tracking technology in their marketing emails, turning inboxes into a de facto surveillance tool during the holiday shopping season.

Article illustration 1

According to Proton Mail's new research, "Spam Watch: The US Inbox Overload + Hidden Tracker Report," retailers across the US are employing sophisticated tracking methods that monitor user behavior without explicit consent. The analysis, conducted between November 4 and December 1, found that these companies send approximately 1.3 billion marketing emails daily during standard weeks—a volume that nearly doubles to 2.55 billion emails per day during the Black Friday to Cyber Monday shopping surge.

The Mechanics of Email Tracking

The report highlights how tracking pixels—small, invisible embedded images—work as surveillance tools within marketing emails. These pixels, along with tracker links, log information on recipients' locations, email open times, and device types. This data collection occurs silently, often without users' knowledge or consent.

"The Spam Watch findings confirm a harsh reality: the inbox has become a high-volume, high-noise channel where brands battle for attention while silently gathering data on every open," commented Anant Vijay Singh, Head of Product at Proton Mail. "This is not accidental—it is an engineered assault on your attention and your privacy."

Article illustration 2

Tracking by the Numbers

Proton Mail's analysis reveals significant variations in tracking practices among retailers. While some companies flood inboxes with numerous emails, others employ a more targeted approach with higher tracking intensity.

The report identifies several categories of tracking offenders:

High-Volume Trackers

These retailers combine high email volume with substantial tracking technology:

  • CB2: 13.00 trackers per email, 2.11 emails per day (score: 27.39)
  • Anthropologie: 12.90 trackers per email, 1.88 emails per day (score: 24.31)
  • Victoria's Secret: 13.84 trackers per email, 1.57 emails per day (score: 21.75)
  • VS Pink: 14.00 trackers per email, 1.14 emails per day (score: 16.00)

The "Silent Stalkers"

This group sends fewer emails but employs aggressive tracking tactics:

  • VS Pink: 14.00 trackers per email
  • Victoria's Secret: 13.84 trackers per email
  • CB2: 13.00 trackers per email
  • Anthropologie: 12.90 trackers per email

The report also identifies the "100% Club," consisting of 40 out of the 50 audited brands that included at least one tracker in every email sent. For these retailers, tracking is not optional but a "hardcoded default."

Privacy Implications and Developer Considerations

From a technical perspective, email tracking relies on several mechanisms:

  1. Tracking Pixels: These are typically 1x1 pixel images hosted on the retailer's server. When the email is opened, the image is requested, revealing the IP address, timestamp, and other metadata.

  2. Tracker Links: URLs embedded in emails that redirect through tracking servers before reaching the final destination, collecting data along the way.

  3. Fingerprinting: Some advanced tracking methods combine multiple data points to create unique user profiles even without traditional identifiers.

For developers and security professionals, these practices raise significant concerns about:

  • Consent and Transparency: Users rarely provide informed consent for this level of tracking
  • Data Security: Collected data may be vulnerable to breaches or misuse
  • Profile Building: Aggregated data creates detailed user profiles that can be used for behavioral manipulation

Retailers Resisting the Trend

Not all retailers have embraced invasive tracking practices. Six companies audited during the study period sent marketing emails without any tracking pixels or links:

  • Bass Pro Shops
  • Burlington
  • Dillard's
  • H&M
  • New Balance
  • TJ Maxx

These retailers demonstrate that effective marketing can be conducted without compromising customer privacy.

Technical Solutions for Privacy-Conscious Users

For individuals seeking to protect their privacy, several technical approaches can mitigate email tracking:

  1. Email Client Filtering: Services like Proton Mail automatically strip tracking pixels from emails before they reach the inbox.

  2. Disposable Email Addresses: Creating separate email addresses for different purposes can limit data aggregation.

  3. Privacy-Focused Browsing: Using browsers with enhanced privacy protections can prevent additional tracking when clicking through emails.

  4. Unsubscribing Strategically: Regularly unsubscribing from unnecessary mailing lists reduces both email volume and potential tracking exposure.

As the holiday shopping season continues, the Proton Mail report serves as a stark reminder of the hidden data collection occurring within our most digital communication channels. For retailers, the question remains whether aggressive tracking tactics ultimately build customer loyalty or erode trust in an increasingly privacy-conscious marketplace.