Microsoft has issued a DMCA takedown against indie game Allumeria on Steam, alleging copyright infringement of Minecraft assets and gameplay. The move has drawn criticism from developers and gamers who question the validity of the claims against the voxel-based title.
Microsoft recently filed a DMCA takedown notice against Allumeria, a voxel-based survival game on Steam, alleging copyright infringement of Minecraft assets and gameplay elements. This action has removed the indie title from Valve's platform and ignited debate about copyright boundaries within the sandbox gaming genre.
Valve notified developer unomelon that Microsoft representative Judith Woodward specifically cited unauthorized use of content from minecraft.net, including gameplay mechanics and visual assets. According to Steam's standard policy, the game was immediately removed to avoid potential legal action. Unomelon has the option to file a DMCA counter-notice, which would require Microsoft to initiate formal legal proceedings within 10 days to maintain the takedown. However, the developer expressed hesitation about challenging Microsoft's legal resources without costly representation.
The takedown has drawn criticism from industry peers. Tyron, creator of the sandbox game Vintage Story, publicly supported Allumeria, noting key technical differences: "Allumeria utilizes a different programming language and features a distinct art direction." This perspective highlights the tension between copyright protection and genre conventions, where many games share foundational voxel mechanics pioneered by Minecraft.
Visual comparisons reveal why Microsoft targeted Allumeria. The game's demo trailer shows block textures, inventory interfaces, and environmental structures strikingly similar to Minecraft's signature style. Unlike more transformative Minecraft-inspired titles like Hytale, Allumeria's visual presentation hews closely to Mojang's aesthetic. However, unomelon contends Terraria served as primary inspiration, emphasizing Allumeria's combat-focused progression system and built-in block customization tools that eliminate the need for mods.
This situation raises critical questions about copyright enforcement in game development:
Genre Standards vs. Infringement: When do common genre conventions become copyright violations? Voxel games inherently share visual similarities, making infringement determinations subjective.
Selective Enforcement: With numerous Minecraft-inspired games available on Steam, why was Allumeria singled out? Some speculate automated content identification systems might have flagged it erroneously.
Developer Vulnerability: Indie studios lack resources to contest corporate legal actions, creating an imbalance even when claims appear questionable.
The outcome now hinges on whether unomelon files a counter-notice. If Microsoft doesn't pursue litigation, Allumeria could return to Steam. However, the case already demonstrates how copyright claims can significantly impact smaller developers operating in popular genres. As voxel games continue evolving, this incident may prompt clearer industry guidelines distinguishing inspiration from infringement.
Source: Tyronmm X account, Unobtainable Melon YouTube
Comments
Please log in or register to join the discussion